View Larger Map
ArcGIS ONLINE: ESRI is a good place for most GIS folks to start because it works well with their desktop environment and is immediately comprehensible. I like working with web-based platforms because there’s no software download. The downside is that (without getting into the code) you have little control over legend, which takes up an awful lot of space (my GIS trainings in Bangkok got bumped out of frame) and there doesn’t appear to be an immediate way to handle clustering: zoom to the U.S. State of Georgia or my work in the Congo Basin to see how much I’ve actually done there.
View Larger Map
GOOGLE MAPS: Well, Google just generally scores really high marks for being ridiculously easy to use and, again, it’s web-based (no software download). I played with both Fusion Tables (which is a cinch to update) and Google maps (I couldn't find an immediately easy way to link Google Maps to my Fusion Tables maps, which offer less customization). The downside is that Google seems more run by developers than cartographers and embeddable maps have no legend. Clustering remains a problem and you don’t get as many base-map choices as you do with ESRI.
View Larger Map
MAPBOX: Okay, so map box took waaayyy longer than an hour and I had to download TileMill. What can I say? Sexy as hell: that’s what. Mapbox gives you, hands down, the most cartographic and design control. If you already write CSS or HTML learning CartoCSS will come very quickly. Although I did have a fair share of bugs while crafting the map in TileMill and exporting to MapBox, I found the online support to be incredibly quick and helpful. For a freebie service this was impressive. So, on the balance, a lot more work for a quick map but well worth it.
Hello, have you tried www.cartodb.com ?
ReplyDeleteBye.
I haven't, but I will now! I've actually been working with MapBox a bit but it was taking more than an hour to work out some bugs with their CSS-esque language so I haven't gotten that up yet. Thanks for the link!
DeleteThis is awesome! I'm totally making one of these!!
ReplyDelete